Told It Might Be Functional: The Lyme Infection Behind a Man's Involuntary Movements

Author profile image FND Nope Moderator
0 comments

A man in his 70s developed severe arm pain followed by involuntary movements that spread throughout his body. After multiple emergency department visits, he was prescribed pregabalin and told he might have a functional disorder. No investigations or antibiotics were initially ordered. By his third emergency visit, clinicians finally considered Lyme disease, and subsequent investigations revealed an infectious neurological condition with objective abnormalities in his spinal cord and cerebrospinal fluid.

The case, published in BMJ Case Reports in December 2019 under the title Lyme neuroborreliosis presenting as spinal myoclonus, raises an uncomfortable question about diagnostic reasoning: how does a patient with a recent history of tick exposure, characteristic skin rashes and progressive neurological symptoms reach multiple emergency departments without an appropriate investigation of the possible infectious cause?


The Clinical Presentation

The patient had recently returned from the Czech Republic, where he experienced multiple tick exposures and developed a large circular rash on his arm, consistent with erythema migrans. He received only three days of amoxicillin, after which the rash resolved. Another circular rash subsequently appeared on his thigh following a tick bite. Approximately three weeks later, he developed severe radiating pain in his left arm, followed by involuntary jerking movements.

The movements initially affected his left arm but progressed within a week to involve his opposite arm, both legs and his trunk. The presentation was consistent with propriospinal myoclonus, a movement disorder involving involuntary muscle jerks associated with spinal motor pathways. Although uncommon, this manifestation of Lyme neuroborreliosis had already been described in the medical literature.

The authors describe the initial medical response:

He presented to multiple emergency rooms and was given pregabalin, however no antibiotics or investigations were ordered and he was told he may have a functional disorder.

This distinction matters. The report does not establish that clinicians made a formal FND diagnosis using positive neurological signs. It documents something narrower, but still concerning: a functional explanation was suggested while a plausible infectious cause remained uninvestigated. The patient's unusual movement presentation appears to have complicated recognition of the underlying disease, despite a history that warranted consideration of Lyme neuroborreliosis.


What the Investigations Revealed

During his third emergency department visit, Lyme disease was suspected and infectious disease and neurology specialists became involved. A lumbar puncture revealed cerebrospinal fluid inflammation, including an elevated protein concentration and a white blood cell count of 41 cells/ยตL, predominantly lymphocytes. Spinal MRI demonstrated abnormal enhancement of the cauda equina nerve roots and anterior spinal cord at C5โ€“C6. Lyme serological testing was reactive, with subsequent European testing identifying antibodies to Borrelia afzelii.

These findings provided evidence of an inflammatory neurological process consistent with the patient's exposure history and clinical presentation. The patient received intravenous ceftriaxone and oral doxycycline during a prolonged treatment course. His spinal myoclonus and radiating arm pain improved and eventually resolved, with the authors reporting no residual neurological symptoms.

The clinical outcome is significant because the eventual diagnosis was supported by more than the patient's subjective experience or the apparent effectiveness of treatment. There were documented inflammatory abnormalities, relevant serological findings, characteristic exposure history and MRI changes. The subsequent recovery following antibiotics further supported the infectious interpretation.


An Unusual Presentation Was Not an Unknown Presentation

One particularly revealing aspect of the report is that Lyme-associated spinal myoclonus was not a newly discovered phenomenon. The authors referenced a 1996 report of Lyme neuroborreliosis presenting with propriospinal myoclonus, along with other reports of myoclonus associated with neuroborreliosis. A 2013 case report had also documented startle myoclonus induced by Lyme neuroborreliosis.

These earlier publications do not establish that every clinician should immediately recognise this rare presentation. They do, however, demonstrate that the association was already documented. When an unusual neurological presentation occurs alongside a relevant exposure history, rarity should not become a justification for overlooking a potentially treatable disease.


The Common Phenotypes Problem

This case illustrates a central concern underlying the Common Phenotypes Hypothesis: similar clinical presentations can arise from different underlying conditions, and the appearance of a symptom does not establish its cause. Involuntary movements, weakness, gait abnormalities and other neurological presentations may occur across disorders with very different mechanisms. The diagnostic challenge is to distinguish between those causes rather than allowing the unfamiliar appearance of a presentation to substitute for an explanation.

Importantly, the report does not document distractibility, entrainment, Hoover's sign or other positive signs commonly discussed in FND diagnosis. It therefore cannot be used to demonstrate that those particular signs occurred because of Lyme disease. What it does demonstrate is the danger of introducing a functional interpretation before adequately investigating a clinically plausible alternative. The hypothesis is relevant not because this case disproves the validity of any particular sign, but because it exposes the broader problem of confusing a neurological presentation with an established explanation for that presentation.


The Cost of Premature Attribution

The patient's account provides another perspective on the diagnostic delay. In the published report, he describes encountering several physicians who were reluctant to attribute his illness to Lyme disease and expresses the hope that his experience will encourage clinicians to consider the diagnosis in future patients. His account is consistent with the reported sequence of repeated emergency visits before the infectious explanation was investigated.

The case does not establish precisely why the earlier clinicians suggested a functional disorder, nor does it demonstrate that a formal FND diagnostic process took place. Nevertheless, it documents a troubling sequence: progressive neurological symptoms, an identifiable infectious risk, a suggested functional explanation without initial investigations, and eventual discovery of an inflammatory neurological disease.

The lesson is not that every patient with involuntary movements requires indiscriminate testing for Lyme disease. It is that clinical history, exposure risks and disease progression must remain central to diagnostic reasoning. A functional explanation should not become a convenient stopping point when the evidence points towards an alternative that has not yet been properly examined.


References